Benefit goof proof eyebrow pencil — Shades & Swatches
The Benefit goof proof eyebrow pencil eyebrow comes in 6 shades. Here's the swatch chart — plus how to find the one that actually matches you.

The shade read
These 6 shades are mostly in the orange/coral, red, grey/taupe families. Which of these shades flatter you comes down to your colour season. Makeup Check AI reads your season from a selfie — free — so you pick the ones that make you glow.
All 6 shades
About
super easy brow-filling & shaping pencil
Which shade is yours?
Stop guessing from swatches on a screen. Scan your face free — your undertone and colour season, read in seconds. Your photo never leaves your device.
Analyze my face freeMore from Benefit & eyebrows
- Benefit creaseless cream eyeshadow10 shades
- Benefit hydra-smooth lip color10 shades
- Benefit hello flawless! powder foundation9 shades
- Benefit brow zings eyebrow shaping kit6 shades
- Benefit ka-BROW! eyebrow cream-gel color6 shades
- Benefit precisely, my brow eyebrow pencil6 shades
- Benefit ultra plush lip gloss6 shades
- Benefit they're real! gel eyeliner pen5 shades
FAQ
How many shades does the Benefit goof proof eyebrow pencil come in?
It comes in 6 shades. The full swatch chart is above.
Which Benefit goof proof eyebrow pencil shade should I get?
Which of these shades flatter you comes down to your colour season. Makeup Check AI reads your season from a selfie — free — so you pick the ones that make you glow. Scan your face free to get a personalised match instead of guessing.
Where can I buy the Benefit goof proof eyebrow pencil?
You can buy it direct from the brand — see the "Where to buy" link above (around $30.00).
Shade names, swatches and prices are drawn from public catalog data and can vary by retailer, batch and region; on-screen colours are approximate. Makeup Check AI is not affiliated with the brands listed. Undertone and season reads are guidance, not a guarantee — your best match depends on your own skin.